Scrolling through news and social media, catching up on the terrible events of the world and smiling at cute stuff is a form of daily prayer. My tracking pad doubles as a worry bead over which I pass my hand, muttering, whispering, hoping and fearing as I contemplate the twists and turns of the Syrian conflict, Brexit, Trump, the refugee crisis, #Metoo, Yemen, the far right rise in Europe, Brazil, the levelling out of biennales and art fairs, the rise of the auction house and all the ecological stuff.
The world is getting worse and there seems little I can do. I wish , I hope , I sometimes post things for people who I think think like me. I snarl at my screen.
I experience a lot of the world via metal, plastic, semiconductors and satellites. If only there were no screen to snarl at, I might feel I had more agency,since I’d perhaps be living more according to my scale: flesh, tables, doors, windows, stairs and streets.
It seems that the need for solidarity, for agency, for some kind of hopeful ontology in the face of new challenges is weighing down on 99% of the world.
I switch off my computer and in the black reflection of the screen I see the room I am sitting in and the paintings I am working on. This is the reality that I had temporarily scrolled into oblivion. In the middle of the screen is a face not quite sharp under dust and smudges. It’s me.
I see myself through a glass darkly: a phrase from St Paul that I first read when very young, not knowing what it meant then, that there were mysteries framed with no answer to be gained in the present, and here I am now godless - in a black screen- no wiser really.
For now we see through a glass, darkly; but then face to face: now I know in part; but then shall I know even as also I am known. ( 1 Corinthians 13 12-15)
I am quoting from the bible in my head. I feel embarrassed. It’s difficult to shuffle off the gods of one’s childhood. Even when we banish them into obsolescence alongside toys and story books decrying their lack of scientific fact and their perpetualisation of a patriarchy, they lie at the base of our abstract, archetypal and symbolic language: Adam and Eve, Sodamm and Gomorrah, heaven and hell.
That line of St Paul’s quoted above, is preceded in the same Chapter 13 by a lament that until we come to live in solidarity with strangers in the spirit of charity or agape - we shall live like atomised body parts: ears, eyes, mouths incomplete, inchoate and frustrated floating in ignorance. That combination of enlightenmnet and solidarity sounds great! Too bad it hasn’t happened yet. Maybe consciousness is supposed to be disembodied? Ibn Arabi the twelfth century Sufi mystic seemed to think so. He also spoke of a clouded mirror similar to St Paul’s. For Ibn Arabi, the fogged mirror is the human heart which needs polished so that God can see himself. Arabi sees mankind as the pupil in a vast cosmic eye: God sees through us and we through him. By polishing the mirror through embracing Islam, a person can eventually attain perfection. I have often tried and failed to draw a diagram of this mechanism.
I also cannot enthuse about being a component in a cosmic all seeing eye although there are observable similarities between being a node to facilate the conduit of some vast stream of images and life spent online. Both dangle a carrot of happiness in front of our noses provided we pay homage to a narcisistic inner tyrrant. Is this a description of Facebook?
There is a lack of solid objects of materiality.
All this talk of man and God perpetuates for many the historical problem of patriarchy and fear. As Meister Eckhart famously said also in the twelfth century the idea God is a problem – he was excommunicated soon afterwards.
If you open up the Moses basket of religion, inside the basic content is the same. A baby needing cared for: the epitome of human fragility.
Freud claimed that the origin of human ethics is the silent accord of care between adults and tiny infants. He goes on to say that bond is so strong that after the realisation by an infant that they and their mother are not one unified body but separate entities, they have a sense of being incomplete that follows them on their lonely and often fearful journey through life.
We fear loneliness and we long for a spiritual home. We fear strangers and we fear suffering.
Fear of the stranger of the other and fear of suffering is the ancient belief system that humanity in its rawest state is ineluctably forced to participate in. People throw themselves into flimpsy boats to escape war and economic hardship or wrap SUVs around themselves to drive their children to private schools because they fear class war and fute economic hardship and the poverty others. We all fear the policeman’s truncheon.
St Paul sees agape as being achieved through embracing the teachings of Christ. Subversion of hierarchies, redisdribution of wealth all men and women equal. It was a plan that Marx found much to agree with on the main points. For a Marxist Dominican monk like Herbert McCabe these were ever mutually exclusive approaches. . Having largely uncoupled myself from the gods of my childhood, I imagined that most forward thinking intellectual types were atheists or agnostics who had internalised Christian ethics post Spinozian Pantheism, post Kantian pietism, post Marx, but there are a lot of churchgoers and praying folk.amongst them and I’m often surprised to learn that friends whom I assumed to be atheists or agnostics confide that they maintain some form of religion inherited or acquired in later life. Maybe religion is cool: Warhol was a practicisng Catholic and had an altar at home and Wim Wenders just made an optimistic movie about Pope Francis
I used to be an optimistic person, I think I still am: I must be if I am a painter in the 21st Century.
I turn from the screen and see my own pile of paint tubes and brushes in jars, palettes piled up, rags and turpentine: a technological landscape that hasn’t changed much for a thousand years, but also a mode of making in response to being that is the continuity of a daily practise of seeing through colour and line unbroken since childhood. In the lines before the dark glass, come the famous: when I was a child, I thought as a child I acted as a child, now I have put childish things behind me. I haven’t put them away art feels like a complex development of play. What agency in painting then? What in art? Is agency related to usefulness? To being ‘in the field’ researching like many contemporary artists rather than in the studio? How effective is research that is never scientifically tested and floats in a paper boat of good intention. It could be argued that it would better to become a war correspondant and document it at all at close quarters with a camera, rather than simply meeting the world half way. I knew someone who did just that and got hooked on the adrenaline and spectacle of war later finding normal civilian life hard to bear. I owe him a debt of gratitude however, since he also suggested I visit Peshawar in North Pakistan.
Nowadays I only visit Peshawar from the safety of my screen, as a disembodied eye flying up amongst the gazing orbs of predator drone pilots whose own soft flesh is safely sat slurping Starbucks in a cubicle somewhere in Utah. New Year 1993 I found myself physically there standing in a small concrete room in with a strip light flickering overhead. From a narrow slit of yellow fogged glass - the only window in the room and placed too high up in the wall to see out of- urinal winter light landed on two oriental cushions lying like blue and silver slugs against one wall- the only furniture in the room. Against the other wall a dozen small paintings were propped in a row. The artist I was visiting was one of three and a half million Afghan refugees living there. His name was Abdullah Aziz, he was around 40 years old.
The paintings looked as if they had been done by a seven year old child. They were mostly landscapes. waterfalls, a man and a woman in a rowing boat, rainbows, children running all painted in raw primary colours. I had been standing alone with the paintings for about ten minutes while my host mades tea on a gas burner in the cupboard that served as his kitchen. It was a classic studio visit feeling. Tension, what to say- if anything at all? Be direct? ‘It’s good for people to have their illusions shattered’. Be nurturing? ‘Painting requires time, many bad ones before the good come’.
He came in grinning with two handleless little cups half filled with green tea. There was a crack at the lip facing me and I turned it round before pressing my mouth to the smooth side to take a sip and play for time before speaking. The man’s eys had not left my face. He was desperate for a reaction.
The context was bizarre. We had met the previous day when he stood by me as I drew portaits of people working at the post office counter. He followed me to a restaurant, insisted on buying me lunch, invited me here. I almost didn’t survive the bus journey across town when a surly young ticket seller tried to drag me from the bus and make me me kneel on the pavement to pray with the other male passengers when the bus made an unscheduled stop at a mosque. I was trying to get across town on public transport and didn’t have the vocabulary to explain that I was a lapsed Catholic who had given up praying to paint because art had replaced religion as my spiritual activity. I resisted the young man’s tug on my sleeve saying in broken Urdu ‘I am not a muslim!’, but -since declarations of atheism in that part of the world can provoke fury - added, ‘ my God is your God’. This salvatory reference was picked up by an old whitebeard sitting opposite who told the youth to lay off, reminding him that I belonged to the ‘people of the book’ – the book in question being the common texts found in the Torah, Bible and Koran. He let go of my sleeve and as he did so he hissed the word ‘Kaffir’ – infidel- at me.
Now in Abdullah Aziz’ place I felt safe again amongst these paintings although I thought they were truly awful. I felt comforted looking at his palette and brushes and tubes of acrylic piled up in a corner. We spoke a mixture of Urdu and English as he explained how sad the situation in Afghanistan was and how these pictures were a vision of a better future. I think I guessed all that before he opened his mouth. I politely said they were very nice then asked him if this was‘all’ he did? Sit in this miserable room and paint?
From a shelf in the kitchen he fished out a floppy photo album with pictures in polythene sleeves.
Standing before me he appeared Chaplinesque in his baggy grey shawar qamis, patched suit jacket and stubble, now in the photograph here he was again but in blue surgical scrubs standing beside a child whose leg was ripped open open from the knee to the ankle. The vividness of such a gory image pulled me in in a way the paintings had not. Another one has him standing beside a doctor who was busy operating on the abdomen of another child. I flick through the book. Its full of images of mostly children with hideous wounds.
-Landmines, he says.
-So you are a surgeon?
- No, surgeon’s assistant. Then sometimes in emergency situations I am the surgeon, when the real doctor is not available.
- You trained for this?
- No I learned through looking. Two weeks in Afghanistan helping mine victims, two weeks in Peshawar painting.
Amateur painter and amateur surgeon.
He still wanted to know what I thought of his paintings, he geninely wanted my reaction. I cautiously suggested mixing his colours a bit more, but was uwilling to pass judgement further. This man was the epitome of human goodness in the face of human suffering. Half his life was a waking nightmare that had not stripped him of his ability to be kind, of agency.
As I saw it then, his paintings were not (yet) good but he seemed to me to be a saint.
He walked me to where the buses sped with past with their scruffy young ticket sellers hanging out at terrifying angles as they shouted destinations and swooped down to snatch potential passengers from the street and drag them on board without the bus ever coming to a halt. Aziz helped me identify the minibus that would take me home. I never saw him again.
As the ticket seller hauled me in through the open doorway, the Kaffir that I was accused of being earlier came to mind. I had been placed in the sub-class of the non believer, irredeemable, worthy of hate and thus expendable. The arabic term Kaffir means veil: since the eyes of the non-believer are screened from the sight of God. Ibn arabi interprets the veil of the Kaffir as a necessary covering the eyes , since the sight of God to the naked eye would be unbearable, unsurvivable. Kantians might see this as a reference to the noumenal world that we are not equipped to perceive.
I said ‘my god is your god’ but I was thinking about art: a white lie to narrowly escape violence.
Was it a lie? Or just stretching the truth? The old man who acknowledged me as belonging to the People of the Book opened up a gap of ambiguity through which I scuttled: we who read are all people of the book since the first books of mythology and of religion are contained and enlarged in all the others that followed like Russian dolls, Wittgenstein saw all philosophy contained in Dostoievsky and Tolstoy who in turn dissected the questions of Christian morality from the bible. My line from St Paul wrapped inside Hannah Arendt.
I looked for the phrase ‘people of the book’ in the Koran and found it in the 43rd Sura also known as the Ankabut- The Spider who had miraculously spun a web to screen the mouth of a cave in which the prophet Muhammad hid from the Meccans during his early years of persecution. At the heart of religion is another religion which is recategorized as mythology. An anthropomorphic spider from Ovids metamorphosis, arachnee the famous weaver who was turned into a spider by Athena for defaming her father Zeus, the Olympian Patriarch by illustrating his sexual excesses in a masterful tapestry, shows up to help a monotheistic prophet. Eight eyes offering a multiplicity of view points and the extra limbs allowing connections to occur in between unlikely places. The moral equivocations found in myth resurface.
Returned from my Peshawari recollection, here I am again back in the blackness still framed in metal, glass, plastic and semiconductors. It felt as if I had lived a decade in that afternoon with Aziz in Peshawar. Today, jaded with experience and gleefully hunched over with irony, I might place his work in the outsider artist category, visually close to Frank Walter but without the hallucinations. ( the Dark side and art agency beckons) . His paintings were therapy, a way to pull a veil over the horrors of reality, inert tokens of his desire for a more beautiful, more peaceful world. The inverse of the simulacra that scrolling and posting on the internet gives of participating in world events gives to me. Painting waterfalls and rainbows was the comforting antithesis of gathering bodyparts from exploded landmines or stitching limbs back together. In is comforting to share an online cocktail of junk, deep stuff and tragedy which constitutes a mirage of solidarity and busyness comforting and compelling in contrast to the silent and solitary activity of painting.
His amateurism places him in the camp of the artist sans metier which I recognise as being part of contemporary art practise. Artists both look for subject matter in the world as well as analizing how they are subject to the world and ultimately objects in it. The fragile ordinariness of being a soft body subject to pain is the central motif- akin to the proliferation of the image of the crucified Christ from our pious past.
There are no longer schools for artists to be part of, so solidarity of style or material has given over to a kind of search for a political and intellectual common spaces, whose ethical compass leads one through the social sciences rather than the history of art. I guess that describes how contemporary art has emerged, in response to absent voices - other than those of the white men - of offical art history. The art object and its syncretic mysteries has tended to fall away and be replaced by an analytical approach that spirals eternally outwards in an encyclopaedic and often paegodical manner. So texts have become even more important than art works, as if a new scripture were required to fill in the blanks left by retracting the old ones. So we remain people of the book, just different books. Contemporary art has its hands full as it seeks to include the entire world and in a space that is heterotopic like a medieval souk or Caravanserai, whose itinerant international polyglots trade ideas and objects and storytellers enthrall audiences. It also has wealthy shoppers wanting to buy their way into art heaven and park some of the cash that global economic inequality has shovelled their way.
The vertigo of being a mutabile being in a mutabile world causes existential dizziness, this is why most of the world practises some form of organised religious. What the artist has going for themself is an acceptance of ambiguity that there is something common amidst this a flux of epic poetry and sacred texts. We can live with compromise. This is the only and necessary compromise that can function across differing taste across differing beliefs.
I carry Azziz in my mind like a cartoon character - Chaplinesque in his baggy grey shawar qamis, patched suit jacket and stubble. He is a paragon of the artist as maker and do gooder. Attached to picture making but with tremendous agency in the world around them. I’m glad to hold him up as a paragon, since I would not want to live his life. If we were characters in a computer game I would have a magic paint brush rocket launcher, lots of books that double up as shields of impenetrable irony to blast the baddies with. I would also carry small pouch of kindness coins to use in emergencies.
He would have no irony shield but he could pelt the baddies with his endless supply of kindness coins. Then again, as an antidote to the hours lost online, painting holds time in a strange way that releases both its maker and its viewers from time’s grip. Hands making something, not typing, eyes attempting to see and not just look. Not just a passing image but an evocation of the world. After the encounter with Aziz and the run-in with the ticket seller I concluded that painting was enough of a contribution, a prayer replacement, a historical engagement, an act of solidarity with strangers, if carried out in a devotional way, if it was a life.
In the end, my own belief – which may well be a matter of taste, is in the possibility of pictures and objects that can punch a hole in time and space. To that extent, contrary to endless out spiralling of the analytical springs of research driven art that exhausts me and only inflates the anxiety of the world spent before screens I am for a syncretic art that holds contadiction and difference together in a holding structure of heterogeneity. My paintings are an attempt at this
Like Abdullah Azziz. I need a veil to throw over the unbearable violence of the world I need to shield my eyes. Perhaps art throws a protective illusion around us like a waking dream that keeps the knowledge of the futility of existence and the inevitability of death at bay
It might be akin to Ibn Arabi’s necessary veil that like a public form of love speaks to the heart. I feel it is closer to a public expression of love for the stranger, for anyone, but not everyone. It is a form of caring generally about everything in the form of dense objects and sophisticated pictures.
Art and religion and violence are a trinity that rose up from the earliest time according Batailles in his Theorie de La Religion. (Sade and le mal) The archetypes supplied by the common texts of the Torah Bible and Koran have been updated and absorbed continuously.
It may well be true that there is no such thing as love only demonstrations of it. I sometimes wonder if the same is true of art. Is art a form of kindness, since to be kind is to be true to some fundamental quality that is at the heart of being human. Art Religion and violence rose up in the same corner of the cave our ancestors inhabited. The tribalistic fear of the other has been handed down to us as well as our propensity to counter that fear with violence. Art may well the atheism to the theism of violence, it requires the violence to make it necessary but it does not rely on belief to convince since it convinces by demonstrating in a mystical way the unflagging endlessly renewed necessity for human kindness.
Kindness is agency.
END